Black Forest Trifle Recipe for Christmas - Cornish Dairy Co

Trewithen Dairy is now Cornish Dairy Co!

November 17, 2026

Black Forest Trifle: The Showstopping Christmas Dessert Made with Cornish Cream

Black Forest Trifle Recipe Small Glasses

This black forest trifle takes everything you love about the classic gateau and piles it high in a glass bowl: chocolate sponge, kirsch-soaked cherries, thick chocolate custard and a rich topping made with Cornish cream. It looks like hours of work, but it’s mostly assembly, and it can be made ahead so Christmas Day stays calm.

If you’re after a proper showstopper for the festive table, this is it. Serve it straight from the fridge and watch the spoons come out.

Jump to recipe

Black Forest Trifle Recipe

Why Black Forest Trifle Is the Perfect Christmas Showstopper

The Black Forest gateau, or Schwarzwälder Kirschtorte, comes from south-west Germany. It takes its name from the Black Forest region, famous for its cherries and for kirsch, a clear cherry spirit. In fact, Schwarzwälder Kirschwasser is a protected Black Forest spirit, made only from the region’s own cherries.

The gateau became a British dinner party icon in the 1970s, and it’s been a much-loved retro classic ever since. Turning it into a trifle keeps that famous chocolate, cherry and cream trio but swaps fiddly cake stacking for easy layering.

That makes it ideal for Christmas. One bowl serves 10 to 12 and it’s a brilliant alternative for anyone who isn’t a fan of Christmas pudding. For more festive inspiration, browse our showstopping Christmas dessert recipes.

What You’ll Need

A black forest trifle has five layers, and each can either be homemade or shop-bought, depending on how much time (and inclination!) you have. Here’s what each brings to the bowl.

Chocolate sponge

The base soaks up the kirsch and cherry syrup, so it needs a bit of structure. A shop-bought chocolate Swiss roll is the easiest option, and the spiral slices look beautiful pressed against the glass. A homemade chocolate sponge baked with Cornish unsalted butter gives a richer, more buttery crumb. For an extra-fudgy version, use chocolate brownies instead.

Cherries and kirsch

Tinned black cherries are perfect here, as they’re soft, juicy and available all year. Frozen dark cherries work well too once defrosted. Kirsch is the classic choice, but cherry brandy makes a good alternative. For an alcohol-free version, use the syrup from the tin instead.

Thick chocolate custard

The custard needs to be thick enough to hold its own layer rather than seeping into the sponge. Homemade custard set with cornflour and enriched with dark chocolate gives the best result. A good-quality ready-made custard from the chilled aisle with melted dark chocolate stirred through is a quick swap.

Cornish clotted cream

This is what makes our trifle different. Instead of topping your black forest trifle with plain whipped cream, we fold Cornish Dairy Co clotted cream through a smaller amount of lightly whipped double cream. The result is richer, silkier and holds its shape far better, so you get those generous, pillowy layers that look as good on day two as on day one. Made with milk from local Cornish herds, our golden clotted cream is what turns a good trifle into a proper delicious Cornish one.

To decorate

A handful of fresh or glacé cherries and plenty of dark chocolate shavings or curls. Running a vegetable peeler along a bar of dark chocolate is the easiest way to make them.

Black Forest Trifle For Christmas

How to Make Black Forest Trifle

There are five simple stages. The custard needs time to cool, and the trifle needs time to set, so start at least half a day before you want to serve it, or ideally the day before.

Step 1: Soak the cherries

Drain the tinned cherries, saving the syrup. Tip the cherries into a bowl with 4 tbsp of kirsch, cover and leave to soak for at least an hour, or overnight in the fridge for the best flavour.

Step 2: Make a thick chocolate custard

The secret to a thick custard for trifle is cornflour. Heat the milk in a pan until steaming. Meanwhile, whisk the egg yolks, sugar and cornflour until smooth, then pour over the hot milk, whisking all the time. Return it to the pan and keep stirring over a medium-low heat until it thickens and just starts to bubble. Take it off the heat and stir in the chopped dark chocolate and a knob of Cornish butter for a glossy finish.

Cover the surface with baking paper to stop a skin forming, then leave to cool completely. If any lumps appear, simply push the custard through a sieve before adding the chocolate.

Step 3: Make the clotted cream topping

Whip the double cream with the icing sugar and vanilla until it reaches soft peaks. In a separate bowl, stir the clotted cream with a spoon to loosen it. Fold it into the whipped cream a third at a time until smooth and streak-free. You’ll find more tips on getting this just right below.

Step 4: Layer the trifle

Slice the Swiss roll into 1cm rounds. Press half of them against the base and sides of your trifle bowl so the spirals show through the glass. Mix 2 tbsp of kirsch with 4 tbsp of the reserved cherry syrup and drizzle half over the sponge.

Spoon over half the cherries, then half the cooled custard. Repeat with the remaining sponge, syrup, cherries and custard. Finish by spooning the clotted cream topping over the top in generous swirls.

Step 5: Chill and decorate

Cover and chill for at least 4 hours, or overnight, so the layers can set and the flavours mingle. Just before serving, scatter over the cherries and plenty of dark chocolate shavings.

Cornish Dairy 200g Clotted Cream for cornish scones

How to Get a Perfect Clotted Cream Topping

The topping is the crowning glory of any trifle. Folding Cornish clotted cream through whipped cream gives you a thicker, more luxurious layer that won’t slump in the fridge. A few simple tips make all the difference.

  • Start cold – Chill the double cream, the clotted cream and even your mixing bowl before you begin. Cold cream whips faster and holds its shape better.
  • Stop at soft peaks – Whip the double cream until it just holds a peak that gently flops over at the tip. It will firm up more once the clotted cream goes in and again in the fridge.
  • Fold, don’t whisk – Clotted cream is naturally thick and rich, so beating it hard can make it grainy or buttery. Loosen it with a spoon first, then fold it in gently with a spatula.
  • Go generous – 300ml double cream and a 200g tub of clotted cream gives a thick, cloud-like layer of around 2 to 3cm in a standard 20cm trifle bowl.
  • Rescue an over-whipped topping – If it starts to look grainy, fold in a splash of cold double cream or milk and it will smooth out again.

Leftover clotted cream? It won’t hang around for long, but here are 11 irresistible ways to use leftover clotted cream.

Make-Ahead Christmas Timeline

This trifle is actually better made the day before, which leaves your oven and your hands free on the big day. Here’s how to spread the work.

Two days before

Soak the cherries in kirsch and keep them covered in the fridge. Make the chocolate custard, press baking paper onto the surface and chill once cool. If you’re baking your own sponge, do it now and wrap it well once cold. While you’re in a festive baking mood, why not whip up a batch of our brandy butter too!?

Christmas Eve

Make the clotted cream topping and assemble the whole trifle. Cover it with cling film, making sure it doesn’t touch the cream, and chill overnight. This is when the layers settle and the flavours really come together.

On the day

All that’s left is the fun part. Just before serving, scatter over the cherries and chocolate shavings. Decorating at the last minute keeps the cherries from bleeding into the cream and the chocolate looking crisp.

Variations and Swaps

Trifle is wonderfully forgiving, so it’s easy to adapt for your guests.

Alcohol-free black forest trifle

Skip the kirsch and soak the cherries in their own syrup instead. Drizzle the sponge with the syrup too, adding a squeeze of lemon juice to balance the sweetness. It’s ideal if children or non-drinkers are joining you.

Individual black forest trifle cups

Layer everything into 8 to 10 small glasses or jars instead of one big bowl. Use smaller pieces of sponge and chill for at least 2 hours. They’re perfect for a buffet or a New Year’s Eve party.

Black forest brownie trifle

Swap the Swiss roll for 300g of chocolate brownies broken into chunks. You’ll get an even fudgier, more indulgent trifle that chocolate lovers will adore.

Not a cherry fan?

Raspberries make a delicious alternative. Use frozen raspberries, defrosted with a spoonful of sugar, and swap the kirsch for a raspberry liqueur or simply leave it out.

Black Forest Trifle Alternatives

Black Forest Trifle Recipe

A showstopping black forest trifle with chocolate sponge, kirsch-soaked cherries, thick chocolate custard and a Cornish clotted cream topping.

Serves10 to 12
Prep time45 minutes
Cook time15 minutes
Chill time4 hours or overnight
Equipment2.5 to 3 litre glass trifle bowl (about 20cm wide)
CaloriesApprox. 560 kcal per serving (based on 12)

For the sponge and cherries

  • 300g chocolate Swiss roll or chocolate sponge
  • 2 x 425g tins pitted black cherries in syrup
  • 6 tbsp kirsch

For the chocolate custard

  • 600ml whole milk
  • 5 large egg yolks
  • 75g caster sugar
  • 3 tbsp cornflour
  • 150g dark chocolate (70%), finely chopped
  • 15g Cornish unsalted butter

For the clotted cream topping

  • 300ml double cream
  • 2 tbsp icing sugar
  • 1 tsp vanilla extract
  • 200g Cornish Dairy Co clotted cream

To decorate

  • 100g fresh or glacé cherries
  • 25g dark chocolate, shaved

Method

  1. Drain the cherries, reserving the syrup. Soak the cherries in 4 tbsp kirsch for at least 1 hour, or overnight.
  2. Heat the milk until steaming. Whisk the yolks, sugar and cornflour until smooth, then pour in the hot milk while whisking.
  3. Return to the pan and stir over a medium-low heat until thick and just bubbling. Remove from the heat and stir in the chocolate and butter until glossy. Cover the surface with baking paper and cool completely.
  4. Whip the double cream, icing sugar and vanilla to soft peaks. Loosen the clotted cream with a spoon and fold it in a third at a time.
  5. Slice the Swiss roll into 1cm rounds and press half against the base and sides of the bowl. Mix the remaining 2 tbsp kirsch with 4 tbsp reserved syrup and drizzle half over the sponge.
  6. Add half the cherries, then half the custard. Repeat the sponge, syrup, cherries and custard layers.
  7. Spoon the clotted cream topping over the top. Cover and chill for at least 4 hours, or overnight.
  8. Just before serving, decorate with cherries and dark chocolate shavings.

Find it near you: look for Cornish Dairy Co clotted cream in the dairy aisle of major UK supermarkets. See where to buy.

Merry Christmas from Cornish Dairy Co - brandy butter recipe

Black Forest Trifle FAQs

Can you freeze trifle?

It’s best not to freeze a finished trifle. The custard and cream can split and turn watery once thawed, and the sponge goes soggy. Instead, make it the day before and keep it chilled. A homemade chocolate sponge does freeze well, though, so you can bake that well ahead.

How long does trifle last in the fridge?

Covered in the fridge, black forest trifle keeps for up to 2 days. Make sure your fridge is between 0°C and 5°C, in line with Food Standards Agency guidance on chilling food. As it contains fresh cream and custard, pop it back in the fridge promptly after serving.

Can you make black forest trifle the day before?

Yes, and it’s even better for it. Assemble the whole trifle, including the clotted cream topping, on Christmas Eve and chill it overnight. Add the cherries and chocolate shavings just before serving so they look their best.

What size trifle bowl do I need?

This recipe fills a 2.5 to 3 litre trifle bowl, roughly 20cm across. A straight-sided glass bowl shows off the layers best. If yours is smaller, make a few individual trifle cups with any extra.

Can I use cherry brandy instead of kirsch?

Yes. Kirsch is a clear, dry spirit distilled from cherries, while cherry brandy is a sweeter liqueur. Both work well; cherry brandy just makes the trifle a little sweeter, so you may want to use slightly less syrup on the sponge.

Can I use fresh cherries at Christmas?

British cherries are a summer fruit, but imported fresh cherries are often in the shops in December. They can be pricey, so use tinned, jarred or frozen cherries for the layers and save a handful of fresh ones for decorating the top.